Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs Nearby Hotels
Considering Blue Flamingo Resort Key West but want to compare other hotels nearby? These guides show how Blue Flamingo Resort Key West stacks up against popular alternatives.
Updated · 19 comparisons
All 19 Blue Flamingo Resort Key West Comparisons

Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection
Blue Flamingo: lively pool scene, shuttle to Old Town. Casa Marina: classic Old Town beachfront resort with private beach and full-service spa.
Compare →
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs Ocean Key Resort A Noble House Resort
Compare Blue Flamingo (New Town pools & family programming) with Ocean Key (Old Town waterfront & full-service spa).
Compare →
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs Pier House Resort & Spa
Blue Flamingo: lively family resort with two pools and shuttle to Old Town. Pier House: classic Old Town waterfront with beach and full-service spa.
Compare →
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa
Compare Blue Flamingo Resort Key West (family, two pools, shuttle) with Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa (Old Town waterfront, marina, spa).
Compare →
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West — 245 rooms, two pools, family-friendly programming; shuttle to Old Town.
Compare →
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs Parrot Key Hotel & Villas
Compare Blue Flamingo Resort Key West (lively, family-friendly, 2 pools) with Parrot Key Hotel & Villas (resort‑style compound, villas, 4 pools).
Compare →
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs The Marker Key West Harbor Resort
Compare a social, family-focused resort near the airport (Blue Flamingo) with a modern harborfront base in Old Town (The Marker).
Compare →
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs Hilton Key West Resort & Marina
Compare Blue Flamingo Resort Key West (family-focused pools & nightlife) with Hilton Key West Resort & Marina (branded waterfront resort with a marina).
Compare →
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs The Reach Key West, Curio Collection
Blue Flamingo: lively pool scene and family programming; The Reach: Old Town beachfront and full-service resort — choose by whether you want pools or sand.
Compare →
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs La Concha Key West, Autograph Collection
Compare a New Town resort with shuttle and multiple pools (Blue Flamingo) vs a Duval Street Autograph Collection hotel in Old Town (La Concha).
Compare →
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs Havana Cabana at Key West
Blue Flamingo: bigger, livelier resort with two pools and on‑site entertainment; Havana Cabana: smaller, Cuban‑themed pool hotel with free parking.
Compare →
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West
Blue Flamingo: lively family-friendly resort with two pools and shuttle to Old Town. The Perry: boutique marina hotel on Stock Island with on-site dock and quieter waterfront vibe.
Compare →
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs DoubleTree Resort
Blue Flamingo: lively family resort with two pools and tiki bars; DoubleTree: Hilton-branded resort with meeting space and airport shuttle.
Compare →
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs The Gates Hotel Key West
Compare Blue Flamingo Resort Key West (two pools, family-friendly programming) with The Gates Hotel Key West (contemporary New Town hotel).
Compare →
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs The Gardens Hotel
Blue Flamingo: lively, family-friendly resort with two pools and shuttle to Old Town. The Gardens: intimate, highly rated boutique hotel steps from Duval Street.
Compare →
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs Southernmost House Adult Exclusive
Blue Flamingo: family-friendly, lively pools and shuttle to Old Town. Southernmost House: adults-only oceanfront inn steps from the Southernmost Point.
Compare →
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs Winslow's Bungalows Key West Historic Inns
Resort energy and two pools near the airport vs Old Town bungalow charm and walkable access to Duval Street.
Compare →
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs H2O Suites
Family-focused two-pool resort with shuttle to Old Town vs adults-only suites steps from Duval Street.
Compare →
Blue Flamingo Resort Key West vs Orchid Key Inn
Blue Flamingo — lively family resort with two pools and shuttle to Old Town; Orchid Key Inn — small adults-only inn on Duval Street.
Compare →
Complimentary Old Town Shuttle
- Lowest rate guarantee
- Complimentary perks & upgrades
- 24/7 concierge